Choosing the Best Fiber for Gut Health

 

 

Because of carbon’s ability to form diverse and flexible bonds with other things, it is considered the building block for all organic, living organisms on earth. Carbohydrates are hydrated carbons, or rather, carbons that are hydrated, hence the term, ‘carbo’-‘hydrates’. Carbohydrates could have easily been also called, “carbo-oxy-hydrates”, since they consist of carbon, hydrogen and oxygen. Carbohydrates are used for energy and to store energy, both for plants, animals and other living organisms. These carbohydrates consist both of simple and complex sugars and are divided into: simple sugar, starch and fiber. In this article, I will be discussing the fiber constituent of carbo-hydrates, the best forms, specifically that of soluble fiber. As an added bonus, I’ll also be discussing resistant starch, and the beneficial short chain fatty acids that can also be derived from them.

Carbohydrates include both fiber and starch. Fiber is divided into soluble and insoluble. Soluble fiber dissolves in water and may form a gel. Insoluble fiber does not dissolve in water. Insoluble fiber is not recommended for regular use, since it is harsh on the digestive system and does not feed the probiotics soluble fiber and resistant starch are known for doing. Insoluble fiber is therefore for temporary use only, for severe constipation. 

In simple terms, the best fiber for gut health, is soluble fiber! This is beneficial for maintaining gut mobility, keeping the microbiome healthy and sufficient, blood sugar balance, cholesterol lowering, the removal of toxins, weight management and cancer prevention.

 

Soluble Fiber

Soluble fiber might help you to move your bowel more efficiently, but that’s probably not its main job. Its main job is to provide nourishment and fuel for your gastrointestinal microbiome, and to manage blood sugar levels.  

There are many forms of soluble fiber. Some are frankly, better than others. If psyllium husk, Metamucil, Citrucel, and inulin come to mind when you think about soluble fiber, keep in mind there may be safer options. Keeping it short and simple, think the best forms of soluble fibers might be pectins, acacia gum and beta-glucan.

Pectins: Pectins are found in fruits like apples and citrus peel, including the “modified”, Modified Citrus Pectin (MCP)

Modified Citrus Pectin is an altered form of pectin where large pectin molecules are broken down into smaller, low-molecular-weight fragments. This modification makes it water-soluble and bioavailable, creating a higher absorption rate within the body, and for use as a detoxification agent by binding to bile acids and heavy metals.

Acacia (Senegal) gum: Also known as gum arabic, this can be found from the sap of the Acacia senegal tree and is sold as a powder; shown to be particularly beneficial for constipation patients with IBS.

Beta-glucans: A type of polysaccharide found in grains, particularly oats and barley. The “best” form of beta-glucan depends on the health goal, with yeast and mushroom-derived beta-glucans being superior for immune support, while oat and barley-derived beta-glucans are most effective for lowering cholesterol and blood sugar. Yeast and chaga beta-glucans, for instance, have shown stronger immune-modulating effects in studies compared to grain-derived versions.

 

Resistant Starch 

Some types of starches are resistant to digestion, hence the term resistant starch. Resistant starch acts like insoluble fiber in the stomach and small intestine. But don’t let that discourage you. In the large intestine, it acts like soluble fiber — fermented by gut bacteria as a food source. This fermentation process produces beneficial short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs) — particularly butyrate — that promote gut health and other physiological benefits. Resistant starch is also known to produce even more beneficial butyric acid than regular soluble fiber; and by specifically bypassing other cells to travel to and seek out colon cells, it offers unique benefits there, like reduced inflammation, and potential protection against colon cancer. 

Perhaps the best sources of resistant starches are from green bananas and green plantain. 

 

Food-source fiber

Perhaps the best sources of food-derived fibers are simply from beans, specifically adzuki beans and black beans. These beans should be soaked for about 12 hours, then thoroughly rinsed, before boiling. Do not expect that these food-derived fibers will resolve constipation!

 

Daily Recommendation 

The current RDI for daily fiber intake for male and female are about 30 and 25 grams, respectively. I find this an impossible number to achieve. Most food-source fiber is only 2 or 3 grams per serving, such as carrots. Furthermore, soluble vs insoluble fiber was not distinguished in the RDI data. 

Instead of 30 grams of fiber to create peristalsis (bowel movement), I think it would be more practical to focus on increasing vitamin B1 intake, which actually helps create peristalsis.  And I may prove it. The same things often mentioned for increasing fiber, are the same things needed to increase B1: [black] beans, green peas, oats, [sesame] seeds, [sunflower] seeds , etc.

 

What to do!

If you are confused about which is the best fiber to take for your particularly situation, think soluble fiber is your best bet. If your goal is to manage IBS, think Acacia Senegal (fiber). If your goal is to detoxify heavy metals from your body, think pectin, especially MCP. If your goal is to build your immune system, lower inflammation and prevent cancer, think beta glucan.

Resistant starch may also be more beneficial than soluble fiber for feeding the microbiome of the colon.

Insoluble fiber — such as wheat bran, flaxseed, quinoa and chia seeds — should serve as your last resort for stubborn and chronic constipation. Consider supplementing with vitamin B1 for a few days instead, as chronic constipation is often more of a muscular coordination disorder rather than a direct, digestive problem.

Irritable Bowel Syndrome May Be Both a Chemical and Mechanical Issue


When doctors narrow down and label your gastrointestinal issues as IBS, what they are really saying is, they don’t know what’s wrong with you! You cannot really blame them for being idiopathic — just the small and large intestine alone can stretch out to 27 feet! Finding what is causing your gastrointestinal issues can sometimes be like looking for a needle in a haystack! In this article, we will look at the chemical and mechanical processes that may lead to IBS, and find that needle in the haystack!

Why it’s so hard to heal gut issues?

The gastrointestinal complex is one big hole with a tube from the mouth to the anus. This hole is exposed to the outside world more than any other organ because, we have to constantly put things in it (including toxins). So it’s like a conveyor belt in a manufacturing facility that never gets a rest. To make things more complicated, this conveyor belt has two main hot regions — the stomach (acid) and the cecum. To make things more complicated, hot “lava” a.k.a. stomach acid, often infiltrate the beginning of the small intestine (the duodenum), and food tends to get stuck in the region between the end of the small intestine and beginning of large intestine (the cecum). Furthermore, the door that opens to the cecum often gets stuck, causing waste product to rot at the entrance of the doorway a.k.a. ileocecal valve.

Gastrointestinal issues such as IBS do not start in the colon — they start in the mouth. It starts with what you put in your mouth and the pH of your mouth. If your saliva is too acidic (5.5) or too alkaline (7.5), there goes your problem. The gram-positive bacteria in your mouth cannot protect your stomach if your saliva pH is not ideal!

The food that enters your stomach cannot be broken down properly if your stomach pH is not acidic enough (less than 2.5). There are certain proteins, enzymes and factors in your gut that will not be released or will not work properly if your stomach is not acidic enough. These include the intrinsic factor that binds to vitamin B12 in the stomach, then releases it into the small intestine; and the enzyme pepsin that helps break down proteins in food. Taking alkaline water or antacids like TUMS for acid reflux may make you feel better, but will surely deplete your stomach acid, leaving you vulnerable to bacterial infections and incomplete digestion of food.

As this broken down food moves down further the gastrointestinal tract, it encounters chemicals. One of the first chemical is bile from the gallbladder, used to alkalinize the acidity from the food coated with stomach acid. Bile release is activated by the existence of stomach acid. Thus low stomach acid equals low bile release. The next is sodium bicarbonate from the pancreas, also used to buffer food blessed with stomach acidity. Pancreatic enzymes, from the pancreas, are also released to further break down food, namely protease, to help break down proteins further; lipase, to help break down fats, and amylase, to help break down carbohydrates.

Now this processed food or chyme now enters the first, second and third parts of the small intestine, called the duodenum, jejunum and ileum, respectively. There, an extraction process goes on, releasing minerals, vitamins, enzymes, amino acids, fatty acid and other nutrients into the bloodstream through Intestinal finger-like projections called villi.

The remaining undigested food is welcomed at the door of the large intestine, called the ileocecal valve. Sometimes this door (that leads to the cecum) does not open all the way. This fully unopened door can sometimes make undigested food feel a little unwelcomed, causing some of it — because of waiting too long — to rot at this junction. This cascade of ileocecal valve dysfunction may lead to all manner of evil: abdominal pain, bloating, diarrhea, constipation and the birth of bacterial overgrowth.

This ileocecal valve dysfunction may also lead to a specific ileocecal valve incompetence — which is actually a real term. From this incompetence, the door of the cecum inappropriately stays open, allowing the movement of waste from the colon to backflow back into the small intestine, from whence it came — leading to all manner of evil: bloating, infections, vitamin C deficiency, emotional instability, diarrhea, and small intestinal bacterial overgrowth.

The food that gets by a properly working ileocecal valve on a timely fashion enters the acidic cecum. Some label the cecum (the beginning part of the the large intestine) as a second stomach, because of the high heat and acids it produces as food travels up the ascending colon.

In the colon, bacteria ferment undigested proteins, carbohydrates and fiber, producing the release of many gases, including hydrogen, carbon dioxide, sulfide, methane and ammonia. Much are recycled, while others are treated as waste product to be excreted.

Bacteria primarily in the colon also break down fiber from carbohydrates to produce short-chain fatty acids (SCFA) — including acetate, propionate, and butyrate  — that nourish and keep colonic cell wall heathy and functional. Other less beneficial SCFA’s include formate, valerate, and hexanoate that are produced in lower amounts.

Water is also extracted from this undigested food and recycled back into the body. If there is some type of dehydration, for whatever reason, the result may become a mechanical issue, known as constipation!

Constipation

Diarrhea should not be labeled as the opposite of constipation — it may actually be a dramatic form of constipation, resulting from watery stool flowing pass impacted stool (or fecal impaction) too hard to move. The closest, official name for this diarrhea system may be called: paradoxical diarrhea. Diarrhea may also be due the ileocecal valve incompetence.

There is acute constipation and there is chronic constipation. Acute constipation only lasts a short period of time throughout one’s life. But chronic constipation may persist for years, even decades. Chronic constipation can lead to other mechanical digestive malfunction, even after the initial constipation situation is resolved.

The devastating effects of chronic constipation:

During chronic constipation or even after it is resolved, almost permanent damage may be done to certain muscular system throughout the colon. It is called anismus aka dyssynergic defecation, specifically paradoxical puborectalis contraction (PPC). What all this means is the muscles of the rectum don’t work — they are unrelaxed and stiff. All of this appropriately falls under an umbrella term called: paradoxical puborectalis syndrome (PPS).

Paradoxical puborectalis syndrome

At the base of the rectum is the control center that regulates all gastrointestinal and urinary activity. It is called the pelvic floor muscles, with a huge sling-like muscle called, the puborectalis.

Many people who suffer from gastrointestinal issues from chronic constipation may have a tight, stiff puborectalis, and not even know it.

Paradoxical puborectalis syndrome encompasses not only a dysfunction of the puborectalis, which is the involuntary contraction and tightening of this muscle when it should be relaxing to allow bowel movement, but also the associated symptoms like bloating, straining, incomplete (stool) evacuation, tenesmus, rectal discomfort and self consciousness caused by this dysfunction.

Treatment for paradoxical puborectalis syndrome:

First, to confirm PPS, you must see a pelvic floor specialist at the PELVIC PHYSIOLOGY CENTER and perform what is known as Anorectal Manometry and/or a balloon expulsion test (BET). If PPC is confirmed, then a series of EMS Biofeedback training may be implemented to retrain and relax the puborectalis muscle and anal sphincter muscles. Additionally, a pelvic floor physical therapist may be recommended to teach relaxation and stretching techniques which target the pelvic floor muscles.

The success rate of the aforementioned techniques is either unknown or very low!

May Be Better Options for PPS:

PPS like most syndromes may be hard to figure out and treat. But these are the recommendations I’ve personally seen and studied success in:

  1. Intimate Rose Vibrating Pelvic Wand
  2.  Sea Buckthorn Oil suppositories 
  3.  Heather’s Tummy fiber
  4.  Various herbs: Andrographis, Punarnava and Bhumi Amalaki

An extreme medical procedure for PPS:

Upon medical request, Xeomin injections into the puborectalis muscle, must be done by a qualified practitioner of botulinum toxin type A — with sufficient hours of experience.

Simply put, this procedure temporarily weakens or paralyzes puborectalis muscle by blocking the release of acetylcholine. This, in turn, relaxes that muscle, and makes bowel movement easier and more complete.

Xeomin® is a purified form of botulinum toxin type A, which lessens the chance of allergic reactions, compared to BOTOX®, which is composed of a mixture of proteins.

Xeomin is considered a neurotoxin, derived from the bacteria that causes botulism. Please read safety studies: click here and here.

 

IBS as a Whole-System Condition 

IBS does not arise from a single malfunction. Instead, it reflects a dynamic interaction between:

  • Digestive chemistry
  • Gut motility
  • Microbial activity
  • Nervous system signaling
  • Muscular coordination

For some individuals, chemical digestion plays a dominant role. For others, mechanical issues such as constipation or pelvic floor dysfunction are more significant. Many experience a combination of both.

Understanding IBS through this broader systems-based framework helps explain why:

  • Symptoms vary widely between individuals
  • No single treatment works for everyone
  • Improvement often requires addressing multiple contributing factors

IBS is real, complex, and highly individualized. Progress often comes not from searching for one hidden cause, but from identifying which parts of the digestive system are most out of balance in a given person—and addressing them thoughtfully.